๐Ÿง What is Good Debt?

Did you know there’s such thing as “good debt?” I’ve got a low-rate (2.45%) mortgage and 0% car loan at the momentito, and we’re going to dive deep into why this is to my advantage.

๐Ÿ“Œ TLDR

SituationTypical “Pay It Off” InstinctWhat “Good Debt” MeansWhy it Can Be Smarter
2-3% MortgageThrow extra cash at the principalKeep the loan, invest the cashHistorical equity returns โ‰ˆ 7-10% (real), tax-deductible interest
0% Car LoanFinish the balance earlyUse the cash to fund a diversified portfolioZero financial cost + potential market gains
High-Rate
Credit Card (15%+)
Ignore it, keep payingPay it off ASAPInterest > expected market returns; this is bad debt

Hungry for more detail?

Animated image of the cartoon character, Sponge Bob, eating cereal for breakfast (Kelpos)

Debt Isn’t a One-Size-Fits-All Concept

When you hear the word “debt,” you probably picture a credit card bill or a payday loan – high-interest obligations that erode your net worth quickly. Those are bad debt, and they should be tackled head-on.

But a 2.45% mortgage or a 0% promotional auto loan lives in a completely different universe. The cost of borrowing is so low that the money you’d otherwise use to pay it down can be redeployed into investments that, over the long run, have a higher expected return.

Like I said, this is the case for me: hubby and I were fortunate to lock in a 2.45% mortgage rate during the pandemic (though I could write an entire post just on the stress of purchasing a home during said pandemic), and I have a 0% loan on my vehicle.

Yes, I know you hate me.

Animated image of a young boy saying, You're tacky and I hate you

Example: $50,000 over 10 years

ScenarioEnding Balance*
Pay extra mortgage – invest $0$0 (You have paid down the loan)
Invest the $50k at an 8% annual return – keep the mortgageโ‰ˆ $108,000 (plus you still own the house)
Pay off 0% car loan, invest remainder at 8%Same math – the loan disappears, the portfolio grows
*Assumes contributions are made the beginning of each year, no additional mortgage principal reduction beyond the required payment.

The math shows that, all else equal, the investment path yields a net gain far exceeding the cost of keeping the low-rate loan.

animated image of a hammer hitting a nail with the captain, Nailed it

Why Low-Rate Debt Can be “Good”

Tax Benefits

  • Mortgage interest is deductible (or you get a credit ) on mortgages up to $750K (for joint filers), which lowers the effective rate.
  • The net after-tax cost often drops below 2% of a 2.45% loan (because of deducting the interest), further widening the gap between borrowing cost and expected market return.

Liquidity and Flexibility

Money left in an investment account can be accessed (subject to market conditions and tax implications) for emergencies, home improvements, or other opportunities, unlike equity tied up in a home you can’t quickly liquidate without taking out a home equity line of credit (HELOC) or flat-out selling. Though there are schools of thought that would use a HELOC as investment funding since the interest is a tax deduction if used as “acquisition debt,” which is to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan. Otherwise, the interest is not deductible.

Leverage Amplifies Returns

Using borrowed money to purchase an appreciated asset (e.g. a home, rental property, or even a diversified stock portfolio) can magnify gains, pwovided the asset’s return exceeds the borrowing cost.

Inflation Shield

Fixed-rate debt becomes cheaper in real terms as inflation rises. If you lock in a 2.45% rate today (though we are not currently seeing mortgage rates this low), a 3% inflation environment effectively reduces your real interest expense to -0.55%.

You get all this straight, Gladys, and you could really maximize them dollars!

Animated image from the movie, Mean Girls, where actress Lindsay Lohan says, The limit does not exist.  The limit does not exist!

Risks & Guardrails

RiskWhat it Looks LikeMitigation
Market VolatilityPortfolio value drops, leaving you “stuck” with debtKeep an emergency fund (3-6 months of expenses) outside the investment account
Rate Changes (if you refinance)Future higher rates could erode advantageLock in a fixed rate, or refinance only if the new rate remains low relative to expected returns
Liquidity CrunchNeed cash, but assets are illiquid or downMaintain a mix of liquid (ETFs, index funds) and less-liquid (real estate, private equity) investments
Behavioral PitfallsOverconfidence, taking on too much leverageSet a clear target debt-to-net-worth ratio (e.g. mortgage โ‰ค 1 x net worth)
Bottom line: Good debt works when you understand the numbers, stay disciplined, and keep a safety net.
Animated image of a man falling onto a net

A Balanced Takeaway

  • Not all debt is the same
  • Low-interest, fixed-rate loans can be a strategic tool for wealth building when paired with disciplined investing
  • High-interest, revolving balances are still the enemy – they should be eliminated first

In the end, the decision hinges on numbers, not emotions. If the cost of borrowing is below what you can plausibly earn by investing, borrowing is not an albatross – it’s a lever – and can be quite powerful.

Animated image of Popeye the Sailor Man cartoon flexing his biceps.

 ๐Ÿ Thatโ€™s the buzz for today โ€“ now go forth and make good financial decisions!

Disclaimer: The Budget Bee provides educational content only and does not provide individualized financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from ๐Ÿ The Budget Bee

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading